Low Rent Is Only Half the Story: Comparing Rent and Income in U.S. Cities
Compare rent, household income and renter burden in U.S. cities. Original Census analysis shows why lower median rent does not always mean easier housing costs.
By US Cities Info · · Data reviewed
Youngstown, OH reports median gross rent of $728, compared with $741 in San Luis, AZ. The rents are close, but median household income is $34,408 in Youngstown and $59,400 in San Luis. A shortlist built on rent alone misses that difference.
The more direct renter measure also differs: 50.5% of all renter-occupied units in Youngstown are in the ACS categories spending at least 30% of household income on gross rent, compared with 33.6% in San Luis. These are point estimates with visible margins of error in the table. They describe survey-period households, not the budget of a prospective mover.
Selected city comparisons from the source data
These examples illustrate the article’s comparison; they are not a national ranking. Population filters use July 2025. Survey measures use ACS 2020–2024. Dollar estimates are in 2024 dollars; percentages keep their named source universes.
| City | Median gross rent USD/month | Median household income USD/year | Gross rent ≥30% of income percent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Youngstown city, OH | $728 ±$24 | $34,408 ±$2,298 | 50.5% ±4.2 pp 5,531 / 10,944 |
| San Luis city, AZ | $741 ±$78 | $59,400 ±$10,241 | 33.6% ±11.5 pp 1,015 / 3,022 |
| Pittsburgh city, PA | $1,261 ±$27 | $65,742 ±$1,484 | 45.3% ±1.8 pp 32,738 / 72,332 |
| Chicago city, IL | $1,440 ±$10 | $77,902 ±$907 | 45.6% ±0.8 pp 285,719 / 626,193 |
| Austin city, TX | $1,729 ±$14 | $93,658 ±$1,670 | 46.3% ±1.3 pp 119,334 / 257,933 |
| Seattle city, WA | $2,030 ±$22 | $123,860 ±$2,244 | 42.4% ±1.0 pp 86,632 / 204,521 |
| San Francisco city, CA | $2,476 ±$30 | $140,970 ±$2,593 | 37.8% ±1.0 pp 85,000 / 224,913 |
| New York city, NY | $1,821 ±$7 | $80,483 ±$601 | 49.8% ±0.4 pp 1,116,442 / 2,241,032 |
What this comparison can tell a renter
Lower rent reduces one possible expense, while local income helps describe the economic resources of existing households. Looking at both is more useful than treating one dollar figure as a complete affordability verdict. The figures cannot determine whether you personally can afford a lease: your income, household size and other expenses may be different from the city distributions.
Among the 1,946 covered places with at least 20,000 residents, 258 have an exact published median gross rent below $1,000. This is an unweighted count of places, without a precision screen; it is not the percentage of U.S. renters paying less than $1,000. The dedicated lowest-rent ranking adds a documented uncertainty rule before assigning ranks.
Why a ratio of two medians is not a household’s rent burden
Annualizing monthly median rent and dividing it by median household income is simple arithmetic, but the two medians describe different populations. Rent is measured among cash-rent-paying renter units; household income includes owner households as well. Even a renter-only income median would not pair each household’s rent and income before finding the middle ratio.
An actual rent-burden table first relates each surveyed unit’s gross rent to its household income, then groups those ratios. That distinction explains why a city with a favorable ratio of medians can still have a substantial share of renters facing high housing costs. Use B25070 for that distribution rather than describing a ratio of medians as the typical renter’s experience.
Our percentage in this article uses all renter-occupied units as the denominator, including units where the ratio was not computed. Some publications exclude those units and consequently show a different percentage. Both the denominator and excluded category need to accompany a cited number. The linked city cost pages also show the computed-ratio denominator for readers who need it.
Survey rent and the rent on an apartment listing
The ACS gross-rent measure includes contract rent and estimated tenant-paid utilities and fuels. Existing leases, different housing sizes and different local rental stocks contribute to its median. A new listing is an offer for a specific unit at a specific time. Neither measure replaces the other.
For a practical shortlist, use survey rent to identify places to investigate, then compare current offers for the bedrooms and housing type you need. Check which utilities are included in each lease and add separately billed costs consistently. A citywide historical median cannot guarantee an available apartment at that price, and neighborhood averages need their own geographic data.
How to use the city explorer below
Filter by state and a minimum population, then sort by rent, household income or the 30%-and-over rent-burden share. The table preserves each measure’s definition and shows its 90% margin of error. The chart follows the chosen sorting measure and begins at zero. It is an exploration of point estimates, not a statistically tested ranking.
Housing and income use the ACS 2020–2024 five-year window in 2024 dollars. Population is the July 2025 PEP estimate and is used for the size filter. Missing values stay unavailable, and open-ended dollar medians retain their interval labels. Download the complete matching set if you want to reproduce a comparison, then use the source records linked through each profile.
Explore the city data
Search the underlying covered-city observations, narrow the state and population, and choose a measure to sort. The table includes missing and open-ended values when another measure is available. The chart draws only usable exact values for the chosen measure; intervals are never treated as precise amounts.
Loading the full city explorer. The selected source observations above are available without JavaScript.
| City | Population · July 2025 | Median gross rent USD/month | Median household income USD/year | Gross rent ≥30% of income percent |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The interactive table requires JavaScript. Source examples are published above. | ||||
Measures and source universes
- Median gross rent
- Renter-occupied units paying cash rent · B25064_001 · USD/month
- Median household income
- Households · B19013_001 · USD/year
- Gross rent ≥30% of income
- All renter-occupied housing units, including ratio not computed · B25070_007+008+009+010 / B25070_001 · percent
Survey percentages use approximate subset-ratio MOEs from the retained count cells. Population and Gazetteer calculations have no numerical sampling MOE here. Read the calculations and limitations before comparing small differences.
Sources and reproducible analysis
This article uses retained original Census records, joined by exact place GEOID. The data review date is September 30, 2026. Population uses Vintage 2025 estimates; survey observations use ACS 2020–2024. Our calculations describe the covered place universe, with no substitution of county or metropolitan figures. The original records and release manifest are available through data downloads.
- ACS B25064: median gross rent
- ACS B19013: median household income
- ACS B25070: rent as a percentage of household income
Methods and uncertainty explain derived shares, open-ended medians and geographic compatibility. Report a correction with the figure, source and article address. Statistics do not represent personal resident experiences or a universal assessment of a place.
More city research
- Fastest-Growing Cities: Percentage Growth vs. Residents Added
- Where U.S. Residents Work from Home—and What the Data Actually Measure
- Low Home Values vs. Monthly Owner Costs: Two Different Housing Questions
- Commuting Without a Car: What U.S. City Census Data Can Tell You
All city research articles · U.S. city rankings · Compare U.S. cities